"Delivering
Long-Term Shareholder Value"
Remarks by Karen Maidment, Senior Executive Vice-President and Chief
Financial Officer, BMO Financial Group, at 2005 Annual Meeting of Shareholders
Toronto, ON,
February 22, 2005
(Please check against
delivery)
SLIDE 1 to 8
- Annual
Meeting, Forward Looking Statement, Tony Comper, Introduction by Tony
Comper and Fiscal 2004 Financial Results
Thank you, Tony.
Good morning.
SLIDE 9 - 2004:
Achieved Or Exceeded All Financial Targets
I am very proud
to report on an excellent year for the bank – a year in which
we earned record net income, improved our cash productivity, twice increased
our quarterly dividend, and achieved or exceeded all of our financial
targets.
We earned record
net income of nearly $2.4 billion, up $526 million from a year ago.
Earnings per share
rose 29% to $4.42 and return on equity climbed to 19.4%.
Before I talk more
specifically about the numbers for last year and for the first quarter
of 2005, let me take a couple of moments to reflect on the context of
these results.
SLIDE 10 - Profile
of BMO Investors
First, let me say
I believe our performance is being publicly acknowledged. The fact is,
we've been doing well on a relative basis.
However, I'm also
well aware that there are "nay-sayers" out there - those who
like to complain that our bank and our peers are making too much money.
They will argue,
no doubt, that the interests of the banks are pitted against the interests
of the general public.
But the fact is the shareholders of a Canadian bank do represent a broad
cross section of the Canadian public.
As reported by the
Canadian Bankers Association, ownership of the banks is widely held
by Canadians through mutual funds, RRSPs, private pension plans and
public pension plans like the Canada Pension Plan (CPP).
For example, in
2003, nearly 17 million Canadians, or over two thirds of the Canadian
adult population, owned bank stocks through their participation in the
CPP.
Some of you are
here today as retail investors. About half of BMO's shares are held
by retail investors, and they come from every walk of life.
Millions more people
are represented here today by institutional accounts.
These are investors
who rely upon mutual funds to do such things as prepare for their long-term
future, or to put their kids through higher education.
Or people who rely
upon the investments of their corporate pension plans to secure their
retirement.
In fact, the other
half of BMO's shares are held by institutions that manage those shares
for you and me.
Our job, as BMO
executives, is to ensure that we protect and grow the long-term value
of your investment.
We are not in business
to meet the quarterly expectations of the street analysts – although
remaining aware of the expectations of the analysts quarter-by-quarter
does impose a worthwhile discipline.
But no company –
and certainly not BMO – should sacrifice long-term goals for the
short-term game of beating the street estimates.
Sometimes a company
must make tough decisions that hurt in the short term, but pay off in
the long run.
As Tony mentioned,
BMO did this six years ago, when we sacrificed revenue streams to get
out of some lines of business that had low potential, or were unprofitable
or lacked scale.
But as we have seen
over the past two years, these were the right decisions.
SLIDE 11 - Managing
for Long-Term Growth
I'd like to tell
you about five of the key financial parameters that are always top of
mind at BMO when managing for long-term growth and value:
- Improving productivity;
- Growing revenues;
- Maintaining our credit risk management advantage;
- Managing capital; and
- Maximizing shareholder return.
I will refer to
these as I discuss our financial performance in 2004.
SLIDE 12 - Cash
Productivity Improving
First, improving
productivity by growing revenues and controlling costs.
We measure the Cash
Productivity ratio by calculating cash expenses as a percentage of revenues.
This has been our major focus for several years now and is a key objective
once again for 2005.
We improve productivity
on the expense side by using our management skills and leveraging technology
so that it costs us less money to earn every dollar of revenue. We believe
this is a key driver in improving the shareholder value of BMO.
Last year, we spent
63 cents to earn a dollar. That was an improvement from the year before
when we spent 64.5 cents, and the prior year when we spent 67.1 cents.
To put this in dollars,
the improvement in productivity in 2004 added nearly $100 million to
our earnings.
BMO has significant
opportunities to improve our productivity even further in 2005. We are
unique among our Canadian peers in being able to leverage our Canadian
experience with our U.S. franchise. We see this as a significant competitive
advantage, and a key to improving productivity.
SLIDE 13 - All
Operating Groups Are Contributing To Revenue Growth
The second factor
for increasing long-term value is growing revenues.
There is a saying
that nobody ever downsized their way to greatness. Improving productivity
can help us spend less money to earn our revenue, but the real key to
significant growth is increasing revenue.
Last year, all operating
groups contributed to revenue growth. Combined, we increased our revenue
by $341 million to $9.6 billion or 3.7% over the prior year.
That increase climbs
to 6.3% if we eliminate the negative impact of the weakening U.S. dollar
during the year.
SLIDE 14 - Maintaining
Our Credit Risk Management Advantage
The third factor
in managing for the long term is maintaining our credit risk management
advantage.
We lend to individuals
and businesses, and lending carries risk. Some of the borrowers may
default on their loans, and a successful bank must balance short-term
revenue growth and the risk associated with losing money on bad loans.
In fact, one of
the features that distinguishes BMO Financial Group from our peers in
both Canada and the United States is our sophisticated yet prudent approach
to credit risk management.
That's because we
have strong portfolio management disciplines and work hard to ensure
that we aren't unduly exposed to any sector or individual company.
What's more, we
have an excellent team of loan workout specialists whose first priority
is to work with companies to improve their results and get them back
on track. When that isn't a viable option, these specialists focus on
minimizing the Bank's economic loss.
As you can see from
this slide, for the past 15 years, BMO's provision for credit losses,
represented by the yellow line, has consistently been below the Canadian
industry average, as noted by the red line.
The industry has
lost on average 61 basis points per year on loans. At BMO, our average
loan loss has been 39 basis points.
Last year was a
very good year in the credit cycle. Our workout specialists were able
to recover a significant amount of money by applying their best-in-class
loan recovery practices, including selling loans we had previously written
off.
As a result, we
reduced our credit provisions from $455 million in 2003 to a recovery
of $103 million in 2004, including a $170 million reduction in our general
allowance.
That is an improvement
of $558 million before taxes, which added significantly to BMO's earnings.
SLIDE 15 - Managing
Capital For The Long Term
The fourth factor
is capital. We take a long-term approach to managing capital.
We add to our capital
base the earnings of the enterprise and use capital by supporting business
growth, acquisitions, dividends and at times we return capital to shareholders
through a modest share buyback program.
Canadian banks are
required by law to maintain capital reserves to make sure that we have
the cash on hand to meet our obligations – such as money to give
you if you want to withdraw from your savings account.
The Bank Act
requires us to maintain a Tier 1 capital ratio of 7%. We do much better
than that.
Last year, we targeted
a minimum Tier 1 ratio of 8%, and we actually ended the year with a
very strong 9.81% or $13.5 billion. That's an increase from 9.55% at
the end of 2003.
Our strong capital
base gives us the flexibility to do what is best for the long term for
BMO. And, as you can see from this slide, BMO has had 13 years of uninterrupted
dividend increases, which includes our dividend announcement today.
SLIDE 16 - A
History Of Strong Long Term Returns
And finally, the
fifth aspect I want to talk about today is the total shareholder
return.
After all, from
your perspective, everything I have been talking about so far is a means
to an end: making sure that you have a good return on your investment.
Simply put, achieving superior long-term shareholder returns is the
guiding principle in our decision-making.
We measure the total
shareholder return on your investment by comparing the share price at
different points in time and adding dividends.
Growth in earnings
leads to a rising share price. A rising share price, combined with rising
dividends, means that the value of your investment has increased substantially.
In fact, last year
BMO delivered a one-year total shareholder return of 20%, as shown by
the blue bar on this slide with the purple bar representing the performance
of the TSX.
Your five-year total
shareholder return is now 18.9% a big improvement on the 12.9%
five-year average we reported last year.
What does it all
mean? It means that the tough decisions we made a few years ago are
paying off for our investors.
If you invested
$10,000 in BMO twenty years ago, it grew by an average of 17.5% per
year, and today it is worth $252,000.
If you had invested
the same amount in the TSX index of stocks, it would have grown at 9.2%
per year, and today would be worth $59,000. Your BMO investment has
beaten the TSX composite by over 4 times.
SLIDE 17 - Q1
2005 Financial Results
That's a summary
of our fiscal 2004 results. Now, I'd like to move on to the current
quarter's results, which were released this morning.
SLIDE 18 - Higher
Volumes and Lower Costs Drive Earnings Growth
Our first quarter
continues to build on our accomplishments of 2004.
Net Income was $602
million, up $81 million, or 15% from Q1 2004.
Earnings per share of $1.16 rose 16% and ROE improved to 19.4% from
18.3% a year ago.
SLIDE 19 - Financial
Highlights
We improved cash
productivity, our number one priority, by 288 basis points to 61.9%,
as a result of revenue growth of 2.9%, and a decline in expenses of
1.8%.
Adjusting for the
impact of foreign currency translation, revenue rose 5.1% and expenses
were flat.
Results this quarter
and first quarter last year were impacted by a few accounting and special
items.
Excluding these
items in both periods, net income increased 9%.
SLIDE 20 - Net
Income Growth In All Operating Groups
Net income grew
in all 3 operating groups, which I'll highlight individually.
- In Personal
and Commercial Client Group, we saw strong volume growth across all
products, both in Canada and the U.S., and effective cost management.
- Investment Banking Group benefited from both a special item and an
accounting change - an income tax recovery and a change in accounting
for Merchant Banking Investments. Otherwise, reduced revenue due
to less favourable market conditions was partially offset by lower provisions
and good expense management.
- And in the Private Client Group, earnings rose from a combination
of higher fee-based revenues and commissions and lower costs.
Slide 21 - Strong
2004 Performance Against Peer Group
BMO had a strong
first quarter building on a strong 2004.
Last year, we performed
well in absolute terms, and compared to the rest of the financial services
industry.
On this slide you
see the 2004 Canadian Bank Scorecard, which shows BMO's relative performance
to our Canadian Peer Group. Green shows those measures where we ranked
better; red means we've fallen short.
You can see the
strength of our 2004 financial results. In 25 out of 35 measures, we
ranked better than the other Canadian Banks.
We had good revenue
growth, top tier expense management, and we made good progress in closing
the productivity gap on the industry leader.
The results of our
efforts show in the price of the stock. Stock price, of course, is subject
to many variables. We cannot control all of those variables – everything
from the interest rate environment to the value of the U.S. dollar is
well beyond our control.
But we manage the
best we can to anticipate these variables, and respond to protect your
investment.
The rise of the
Canadian dollar against its U.S. counterpart, for example, affects both
revenues and expenses as I mentioned earlier. We can manage for the
effects of foreign exchange volatility.
We have a relatively
well-matched U.S.-dollar balance sheet, as well as a program to hedge
our expected U.S.-dollar earnings. As a result, we have been able to
reduce the impact on our bottom line due to the sharp decline in the
U.S. dollar.
The point here is
that, while there are many factors beyond our control, we remain tightly
focused on managing the factors we can control.
We will continue
to run the company in a prudent manner.
We will continue
to ensure that our corporate governance practices are among the best.
We will continue
to focus on providing better service and products for our clients and
customers.
We will continue
our commitment to return superior shareholder value to you who have
shown such confidence in us by investing in BMO.
SLIDE 22 - 2005
Financial Targets
And with this in
mind, here are our goals for 2005:
- Earnings per share growth of 3 to 8 percent, excluding reversals of our general
allowance in 2004;
- Return on equity of 17 to 18 percent;
- Provision for credit losses of $400 million or less, now anticipated
to be $350 million or less
- Tier 1 Capital Ratio of at least 8 percent; and
- A cash productivity ratio improvement of 150 to 200 bps.
Those are our goals.
I am looking forward to the year ahead, and to reporting a year from
now on how your company has reached them.
Thank you.